Cast iron lasts for decades and suits period homes, but needs painting and rust care. uPVC is cheap and low maintenance. Aluminium costs more but suits exposed coastal homes. If your home is listed or in a conservation area, keep to like-for-like.
Cast iron
Heavy, strong and traditional. It suits Victorian and Georgian properties and can last for decades if it is painted regularly. The weakness is rust at the joints and the underside, and the weight, which needs sturdy brackets.
uPVC
Light, inexpensive and does not rust. Joints use rubber seals that can fail over time, and cheap plastic can discolour or go brittle. It is the usual choice on modern homes.
Aluminium
More expensive than uPVC but does not rust and takes a factory powder-coat finish. A sensible option for an exposed coastal location when you want a metal look.
Listed buildings and conservation areas
Changing the material or profile of guttering on a listed building, or one in a conservation area, can need consent. Ask Dover District Council before you swap anything.
Which is best?
Match the house. Keep original cast iron on a period home if it is in good shape and repair it. Choose uPVC or aluminium for newer homes, and clean whichever you have regularly.